Immigration Expert Consultation

Padilla-compliant immigration consultation for criminal defense counsel — pre-plea analysis, expert declarations, and CLE-eligible training.

Yellow icon of the Emeriti Law PLLC
Close-up view of the Corinthian columns, ornate sculptures, and dome of the US Capitol building under a clear blue sky.
Yellow Circle Frame

Why Criminal Defense Attorneys Need Immigration Counsel — Before the Plea

The passage of the Laken Riley Act, numerous executive orders, and Congress's allocation of $171 billion in new immigration enforcement spending have dramatically reshaped the landscape. The scope of mandatory detention now threatens a broad category of noncitizens — including long-term residents with deep ties to the United States whose criminal cases may trigger automatic, presumptively mandatory deportation.

Under Padilla v. Kentucky, 559 U.S. 356 (2010), criminal defense counsel has a constitutional obligation to advise non-citizen clients about the deportation consequences of a guilty plea. That duty is not discharged by telling a client they "may" face immigration consequences. When the consequences are clear — as they are for most controlled-substance offenses and many theft, fraud, and violence-related convictions — the attorney must provide accurate, specific advice. Failure to do so is constitutionally deficient representation.

The Tenth Circuit's recent decision in United States v. Aguayo-Montes, No. 24-4073 (10th Cir. 2026), illustrates the consequences. A criminal defense attorney told a DACA recipient not to worry about immigration consequences until after sentencing. The conviction triggered mandatory deportation. The Tenth Circuit reversed the denial of the § 2255 motion, holding that the attorney's failure to provide accurate advice was constitutionally deficient.

Aerial black and white view of the National Mall with the U.S. Capitol building centered in the background.
Emeriti Law PLLC logo frame
Aerial black and white view of the National Mall with the U.S. Capitol building centered in the background.

Our Expertise Is Not General Immigration Advice

The founding partners served as primary trainers at EOIR — responsible for teaching newly appointed Immigration Judges the substantive law and evidentiary standards applied to criminal convictions in removal proceedings. Among the former immigration judges now in private practice, few also served as EOIR trainers. Ryan has also served as an ICE prosecutor, a federal AUSA handling major crimes, and an Army trial counsel. He provides expert declarations in proceedings involving the immigration consequences of criminal conduct.

Aliza Lopes Baker has done significant work on the modified categorical approach — the technical analytical framework that governs whether a conviction triggers deportation. She has drafted hundreds of Immigration Judge decisions analyzing these issues from the adjudicator's side.

Our attorneys have seen the consequences of inadequate immigration advice play out from the bench. They bring that perspective to every consultation.

Emeriti Law PLLC single logo yellow

What We Provide

Document magnifying glass icon
Pre-plea immigration analysis
Real-time assessment of how a proposed plea will affect the client's immigration status — deportability, inadmissibility, aggravated-felony classification, and eligibility for relief from removal.
Seal check icon
Expert declarations
Formal declarations for use in criminal proceedings detailing the specific immigration consequences of a conviction
lock icon
Strategic alternative plea structures
Guidance on plea options that may reduce or avoid immigration exposure while addressing the criminal case.
File plus icon
Expert witness services
A-file and case analysis in federal prosecutions under 8 U.S.C. § 1326 (illegal reentry); ineffective-assistance-of-counsel claims requiring immigration-law expertise.
Signature icon
Firm-wide training programs
CLE-eligible training for criminal defense firms and public defender offices on Padilla compliance, the categorical approach, and aggravated-felony analysis.
Yellow Circle Frame
Aerial black and white view of the National Mall with the U.S. Capitol building centered in the background.

Cross-Practice Immigration Consultation

Family law: mixed-status custody, divorce, and naturalization impacts. Employment law: evaluating hiring practices and employment eligibility. Corporate consulting: businesses with foreign national employees navigating enforcement exposure.

The Call That Should Happen Before the Plea

If you represent non-citizen clients in criminal, family, or civil proceedings and need an immigration analysis before you advise them, call us. An opinion letter from former immigration judges who have decided these issues in court carries significant weight — our experience and credibility on immigration consequences of criminal conduct can be a valuable resource for your client. The immigration analysis does not need to take weeks. For most controlled-substance and drug-trafficking charges, the deportability question is answerable quickly — and the answer changes how the entire strategy is framed.

schedule an appointment
Emeriti Law PLLC logo frame
Blue icon of the Emeriti Law PLLC

Your case deserves to be heard.

Emeriti Law was built on the premise that every client — whether a hospital system managing enforcement risk or an individual who never had the chance to present their case — deserves counsel that understands the system well enough to make sure their position is heard.

Our attorneys spent decades deciding cases from the bench. They know what it takes to build a record that holds up, frame an argument that reaches the decision-maker, and present a case with the precision the forum requires. That is the standard we bring to every matter.

Attorney & Institutional Inquiry

For General Counsels & Referring Firms
INQUIRE NOW
Co-counsel engagements, organizational counsel, appellate representation, worksite enforcement defense, and expert consultation on immigration consequences.
Yellow icon of the Emeriti Law PLLC

Individual Consultations

For Individuals & Families
Schedule Consultation
Appellate representation for individuals in removal proceedings, BIA appeals, motions to reopen, and direct representation in complex removal matters.
Emeriti Law PLLC single logo yellow

Integrity-Driven Counsel

The lawyers at Emeriti Law bring judicial integrity to their practice of immigration law. They provide their clients with clear, straightforward guidance on likely outcomes, strategies and risks. As former judges, they provide no-nonsense, honest assessments of a full range of immigration concerns.
Aerial black and white view of the National Mall with the U.S. Capitol building centered in the background.